2009

17

Sep

Why SharePoint hasn’t fixed the corporate intranet (and what you can do about it)

By Dan Hawtrey

SharePoint has launched a revolution in the workplace. Thanks to its easy-to-use collaborative features all employees can now publish information about their projects, initiatives and skills onto the corporate intranet.  We hear stories of blogging CEOs; departmental wikis that allow everyone to post the solution to their problem; forums buzzing with activity. It’s like Facebook, YouTube and Wikipedia all rolled into one. Oh, and don’t forget Google.

Sadly, reality in most companies doesn’t look like this. A typical SharePoint intranet is made up of many, many pages containing poor quality content. There’s an abundance of uploaded Office documents with filenames that tell you very little about the contents (do you really want to click on “pm_update.ppt” to find out what it’s about?). The countless forums you come across contain one or two obviously planted (and unanswered) posts from last year. Content that you do take the time to read is poorly laid out, badly written and boring. Images are either massive and take an age to download or they have been distorted and shrunk beyond recognition. Jo User is poorly served.

So what’s the problem here? It’s the same problem that was there before SharePoint. It’s a human problem, not a technology one. It’s best summed up by the 1:99 rule. For every active content creator, you have 99 mostly passive content consumers. And if one of your content consumers does decide to post something the results are often disappointing. They either don’t have the time or the skills to do it well.

We manage intranet sites for our clients: researching, interviewing, gathering, writing and publishing content. It all takes a long time. It also takes a lot of diverse skills that are rarely found in any one person.

So what should companies do? Should they give up their intranet dreams? Not at all. Here are some pointers:

  • Write intranet objectives – define these in precise terms without recourse to pithy statements like “our intranet will be a  central information-sharing resource for all employees”
  • Clear, simple and well communicated governance is key – define who can publish what and where and plan to avoid the sprawl and clutter that SharePoint is so good at encouraging. Think about quality.
  • Divide and conquer – define responsibilities and ownership for different parts of the intranet and make people accountable
  • Find your content creators – there are people in your organisation who are passionate online communicators who must be involved
  • Appoint an intranet leader to act as quality control, guardian and chaser.
  • Plan and schedule content and make sure the homepage provides continually changing updates to all your latest and greatest content

You can find out more about our intranet site management service here.

Comments

  1. Here’s another interesting article on this subject. This one is aimed at general CMS use rather than SharePoint specifically.

    http://boagworld.com/technology/10-problems-your-content-management-system-will-not-solve-and-how-to-overcome-them

  2. Ian Waugh

    Sharepoint, like any other platform, is just a system. Allowing anyone to contribute content does not replace the need to have knowledgable and skilled people overseeing your intranet.

    Any intranet without a suitable amount of time and expertise devoted to it is fighting a losing battle… proper management and content creation pays for itself in the lost time, energy and frustration that will be avoided, surely?

  3. Ann Marie Weston

    I recommend enhancing your corporate intranet action list by linking intranet objectives with business strategy – that way the “intranet team” isn’t (inadvertently) working at cross purposes to the corporation. With a previous client’s intranet implementation, we also found that governance needed to be both simple and accepted by the content publishers. Finally, content creators needed specific objectives and metrics to keep creating content (it wasn’t enough to find someone with passion, it had to be incorporated into their day job). Your post highlights the interesting dilemma with SharePoint-it’s a cool interactive, business portal that can quickly spiral out-of-control.

Leave a Reply